Jump to the main content

Search Budget Builds Daily

Home Improvement Projects With the Best Return in 2025 Data

Author: Published on Revised Topic: Home Upgrades

The home improvement projects with the best return in Zonda's 2025 Cost vs. Value report are garage door replacement (268% of cost recouped), steel entry door replacement (216%) and manufactured stone veneer (208%). These figures are national averages for hired work, based on Realtor estimates of resale value. Only the steel door is a realistic DIY job for most homeowners.

Two-story house with gray siding, a stone-trimmed entry, black front door and dark garage door

From the guide: Budget Home Improvement: Where to Spend and Where to Save

The home improvement projects with the best return are exterior replacements: a new garage door, a steel entry door and manufactured stone veneer. If you are still deciding how to spend, see our hub on budget upgrades hub first, then use this page to check the numbers.

Which home improvement projects have the best return?

The three best-return projects in the 2025 Cost vs. Value report are garage door replacement, steel entry door replacement and manufactured stone veneer. Each recouped more than twice its average cost. The comparison table above lists them with the next four projects for context.

The report’s analysts link the high exterior returns to buyers who favor good-looking, well-kept exteriors. They also point out that bigger, more complex projects tend to recoup less at sale. Eight of the top ten are exterior replacement projects, and the minor kitchen remodel is the only interior project in the top five.

How does the Cost vs. Value report measure return?

Return is the resale value Realtors estimate a project adds, divided by the project’s average cost. Zonda, the publisher, asked more than 6,000 Realtors what each of 28 projects adds to the sale price of a home.

Three limits matter when you read the numbers:

  • They are estimates. The resale values come from a survey, not from tracked sales of individual homes.
  • They assume paid work. The costs include contractor labor and a standard markup, so they are not DIY costs.
  • They are national averages. Regional results can differ a lot. For example, the report says the Pacific region had the highest average return.

A figure above 100% means Realtors expect buyers to value the project at more than it cost. It does not mean you will profit on every sale.

Is garage door replacement a good DIY project?

Garage door replacement has the highest return in the report, but it is a poor DIY project. It averaged a $4,672 job cost, a $12,507 resale value and a 268% return.

Suburban house front with a new white paneled garage door and a dark driveway

The garage door industry association DASMA says installing a garage door can be very dangerous and is not recommended for a novice, and that spring systems should be repaired only by trained professionals. Cables and brackets are also under high tension. If you want to save money, compare quotes, ask what is included (removal, opener hookup, hardware), and handle painting or trim around the door yourself.

Is replacing a steel entry door a good DIY project?

A steel entry door is the best high-return project for a confident DIYer. It averaged $2,435 and a $5,270 resale value in Zonda’s report (216% recouped), and a new steel front door had the highest cost recovery in the NAR and NARI 2025 survey, at 100%.

The two reports differ because they use different methods and respondents. Both put the steel door near the top.

If you do it yourself:

  1. Buy a pre-hung unit that fits your rough opening, so you do not have to hang the door in a new frame.
  2. Follow the door manufacturer’s installation instructions, including the flashing and sealing steps that keep water out of the wall.
  3. Work with a helper, because doors are heavy and awkward.
  4. Hire a carpenter if the frame, sill or wall is rotted or out of square.

Is manufactured stone veneer worth it for a DIYer?

Manufactured stone veneer returned 208% in the 2025 report, but it is a stretch DIY project. The average cost was $11,702 and the average resale value was $24,328. The study modeled a limited area: a stone “skirt” across the home’s front facade.

Gray stone veneer wall beside a navy front door with a lantern light

Stone veneer needs correct moisture barriers, flashing and fastening, and mistakes can trap water behind the siding. Follow the manufacturer’s installation guide for your product and local code. If you are not an experienced builder, get a bid and keep the job small.

Do kitchen and bathroom remodels pay off?

Smaller kitchen and bath updates return more of their cost than large remodels, but both return less than the top exterior projects. In the 2025 report:

  • A midrange minor kitchen remodel recouped 113%.
  • A midrange bath remodel recouped 80%.
  • A midrange major kitchen remodel recouped 51%.

The report says full bath and kitchen remodels cost a lot and reflect personal choices that may not appeal to buyers, yet still add value to the people living there. For DIY, the lower-cost steps are the ones that make sense: paint, hardware and lighting. Our budget kitchen makeover guide shows how to do that without a full remodel.

Do cheap DIY projects pay off too?

Cheap projects do not have a published return figure, but there is indirect evidence. In the NAR and NARI 2025 report, 50% of Realtors recommended painting the entire home before listing and 41% recommended painting a single room. We found no dollar figures for paint, so we do not give one.

For ideas that fit a small budget, try these guides:

How do you choose a high-return project for your home?

Choose by condition first, then return, then your skills. A new door pays off only if your current one is a problem or an obvious drawback to buyers.

  1. Check what needs replacing. Worn or damaged items give you value and function at once.
  2. Ask a local agent. National averages do not capture your neighborhood.
  3. Match the risk to your skills. If a mistake could injure you or let water into the house, hire a pro.
  4. Set the budget and a contingency. Our guide to how to plan a budget renovation shows how.
  5. Remember it is your house too. A project that makes your home safer or more pleasant can be worth doing even at a return below 100%.

Which projects return the least?

Large additions and high-end upgrades return the least at resale. In the 2025 report, a midrange primary suite addition recouped 32% of its cost, an upscale one only 18%, a backyard patio 46%, and solar power installation 30%. An accessory dwelling unit recouped 41%.

These projects may still be worth doing for space, income or lower energy bills, and the report measures only sale price. Just do not count on a sale to repay them. If you are thinking about an addition, price it against moving or remodeling an existing room.

What does a steel door replacement involve?

A pre-hung steel door replacement takes most of a day for a first-timer, mainly because of removing the old unit and getting the new one plumb and sealed. The steps below are general. Your door manufacturer’s instructions override them.

  1. Measure the opening (width, height and wall thickness) and check which way the door should swing.
  2. Remove the old door and frame carefully, and look for water damage in the sill and framing. Repair rot before you install anything.
  3. Dry-fit the new unit, check the sill for level, and use shims to bring the frame plumb.
  4. Fasten through the shim points with the screws the manufacturer specifies.
  5. Seal and flash the gaps with the foam, caulk and sill pan or flashing the instructions call for.
  6. Adjust and finish: check the swing and latch, then prime and paint any bare areas.

Wear gloves and eye protection, and use a helper for lifting. If the house is pre-1978 and you will scrape or sand old painted trim, follow lead-safe practices; the EPA says about three-quarters of those homes still contain some lead-based paint.

What should you ask a contractor before hiring for these jobs?

Ask for a written bid that lists the product, what is removed, what is included, and who handles permits. That protects you from unclear quotes.

  • Is the price itemized (door or veneer, labor, disposal, trim, paint)?
  • Who pulls permits and what inspections are required?
  • Which manufacturer warranty applies, and does it require professional installation?
  • What is the schedule, and what happens if hidden damage turns up?
  • Do they carry insurance? Ask for proof before work starts.

Get at least three bids, and compare them against the Zonda averages above as a sanity check. A bid far above the report’s average may reflect a premium product, a high-cost market or hidden extras. A bid far below it may leave something out.

What do cost vs. value reports leave out?

Cost vs. value reports leave out comfort, energy savings, safety and your local market. The Cost vs. Value authors note that the report measures only resale value, not the other value a project gives you.

Keep these gaps in mind:

  • Energy savings. A new insulated door or better windows may cut drafts and bills, which a resale figure does not count.
  • Condition and timing. A broken garage door is worth fixing no matter what the report says, because buyers will notice it and you will live with it.
  • Local taste. A project that works in one region can flop in another. Regional results in the report vary widely.
  • Two surveys, two answers. The NAR and NARI report and the Zonda report asked different people different questions and came up with different percentages. Use them as a range, not a promise.
Best-return projects from Zonda's 2025 Cost vs. Value report (national averages, hired work)
ProjectAverage job costResale valueCost recoupedDIY outlook
Garage door replacement$4,672$12,507268%Hire a pro; springs are dangerous
Entry door replacement, steel$2,435$5,270216%Possible for a confident DIYer with a pre-hung door
Manufactured stone veneer$11,702$24,328208%Skilled DIY only; weatherproofing details matter
Siding replacement, fiber-cement$21,485$24,420114%Hire a pro
Minor kitchen remodel, midrange$28,458$32,141113%Part DIY (paint, hardware), part pro
Bath remodel, midrange$26,138$20,91580%Part DIY, plumbing and electrical to a pro
Major kitchen remodel, midrange$82,793$42,13051%Hire a pro

For most homeowners the steel entry door is the best project that is both high-return and realistically DIY. Hire a pro for the garage door, and treat stone veneer as a stretch project. Do not expect big kitchen or bath remodels to pay for themselves at sale.

Questions and answers

What home improvement has the best return on investment?

In Zonda's 2025 Cost vs. Value report, garage door replacement has the best return, recouping 268% of its $4,672 average cost at resale. Steel entry door replacement (216%) and manufactured stone veneer (208%) follow. These are national averages for professionally installed work, and they come from Realtor estimates rather than recorded sale prices.

Are the best ROI projects DIY-friendly?

Only some are. A pre-hung steel entry door is within reach of a confident DIYer. Garage door replacement involves spring systems that the industry association DASMA says should be repaired only by trained professionals. Manufactured stone veneer takes masonry-style skills and careful moisture detailing. Judge each project by risk and skill, not just by return.

Why do some projects return more than 100% of their cost?

The Cost vs. Value report compares a project's average cost with the resale value Realtors say it adds, so a project can show above 100% when Realtors expect buyers to value it more than it cost. The figure is an estimate from a survey, not proof of what any one home sold for.

Do kitchen and bathroom remodels pay off?

Smaller ones do better than big ones. In the 2025 report a midrange minor kitchen remodel recouped 113%, a midrange bath remodel 80% and a major midrange kitchen remodel 51%. The report notes these projects still add value for the people who live in the home, which the sale-price figure does not capture.

Does DIY change the return on a project?

Yes, because the report's costs reflect hired work, so doing part of the labor yourself can lower what you spend while the estimated resale value stays the same. The savings are real only if the work is done correctly and safely. A poorly installed door or a failed seal can reduce value and cost more to fix.

Is a steel front door worth it?

It is one of the best-documented value projects. Zonda's 2025 report shows a 216% cost recouped on an average $2,435 job, and the NAR and NARI 2025 report put a new steel front door at 100% cost recovery, the highest in that study. The two reports use different methods, so expect different percentages.

Should I do these projects before selling?

Do them if the current item is worn, damaged or outdated, and if a local real estate agent says buyers in your market care. Returns vary by region and by the condition of the home. If your door or garage door works and looks fine, a cheaper refresh such as paint, new hardware or cleaning may be enough.

Our sources

  1. Zonda Cost vs. Value 2025: national averages (Remodeling / JLC) (jlconline.com)
  2. Zonda Cost vs. Value 2025: methodology (jlconline.com)
  3. 2025 Cost vs. Value Report: Key Trends (JLC) (jlconline.com)
  4. NAR and NARI 2025 Remodeling Impact Report highlights (nar.realtor)
  5. DASMA garage door systems safety tips (dasma.com)

Related reading

Top of page